Cole & Young Jewelers to close after 146 years

Cole & Young

Owner Larry Mollo ready for retirement after 44 years in Lansing

By Jennifer Yos

LANSING, Ill. (December 22, 2020) – Soon after the first of the New Year, Larry Mollo plans to close his Lansing business—Cole & Young Co. Jewelers—located at 3341 Ridge Road. Mollo has been operating Cole & Young at the Lansing location since September 7, 1976. This permanent closing will not only mark the beginning of Mollo’s retirement after 47 years in the jewelry business, but will also conclude a Cole & Young proprietorship lineage that began 146 years ago with founding owner and namesake jeweler Warren Cole.

Mollo would have preferred to stay open another four years to mark and celebrate 150 years of continuous business, but current economic factors make that all but impossible. Mollo explains: “This is a perfect storm for a business closing—Amazon, pandemic, recession…” He also mentioned “crazy-high taxes” as a factor.

After 47 years, Mollo is ready for retirement. “I’m 68 years old. Worked six days a week since 1968. I’m done,” he said. In retirement, he and his wife Barb plan to visit their son Lonnie, who is a doctor in Minneapolis, their daughter-in-law, and their three-year-old granddaughter Lucy.

Mollo has already begun a soft closing, keeping Cole & Young open Wednesdays, Fridays, and Saturdays only. He currently is running a “Going-out-of-business” sale.

Cole & Young
Owner Larry Mollo (right) and his wife Barb stand at a counter in their Lansing jewelry shop directly below a framed photo of the former Cole & Young Co. storefront at 9144 Commercial in South Chicago, where Larry first took over the jewelry business 47 years ago. (Photo: Jennifer Yos)

146 years: A Cole & Young timeline

The following timeline features highlights of Cole and Young’s local history in Crown Point, IN; South Chicago; and Lansing from 1874 to present.

19th Century

  • In 1874, farmer Warren Cole establishes his first jewelry business in Crown Point, IN, several years prior to a partnership with Young. 
  • In 1883, Cole completes a brick-and-mortar store in Crown Point’s town square at a time when business development is booming. The Crown Point Register, dated November 14, 1878, reports:

A new brick block will be erected on the ‘Goulding corner’ next spring. Mr. F. Goulding, Mr. W. Cole, and the First National Bank being the builders. We hope Mr. Sauerman and the other property owners east of him will also conclude to build at the same time, and that Mrs. Fraas will also erect a building on the Schlemmer corner, and then we will have an unbroken row of brick stores on the east side of the public square. Enterprise, gentlemen!

Crown Point
Above left: Twelve Islands Harbor Room in Crown Point is the original location of Warren Cole’s first brick-and-mortar jewelry story. Above right: a marker above the last window on the left reads “W. Cole A.D. 1883.” (Photos: Jennifer Yos)
  • In 1886, Warren Cole’s daughter Alice marries William J. Young; his son-in-law will eventually become his future partner in Cole & Young Jewelers.
  • In 1889, Cole considers relocating his Crown Point business to either South Chicago or Portland, Oregon, as the Crown Point Register reports on September 5, 1889:  

Warren Cole, the jeweler has not made up his mind to go to South Chicago, or to Portland, Oregon. The fact is he rather expects to stay in Crown Point, where he is doing a safe business. The REGISTER last week said that Mr. Cole had leased his store rooms; but he had not. The bargain talked of was conditional, and as the matter now stands he will remain where he is and has been.   

Rumors of relocation, however, apparently carry some truth as the Register announces two months later on November 7, 1889:  

It was reported on Monday that Warren Cole, the jeweler, has sold his business house on Main street to Eder Bros. for $7,000. The papers had not been signed on Tuesday. Mr. Cole went to South Chicago to look at some property there to invest his money in, provided the chances seem favorable. He will not leave Crown Point for the present, even should he sell here and invest in some other place.

  • In 1891, Cole relocates his jewelry store to 9144 Commercial Avenue, South Chicago, and enters into a partnership with his son-in-law William J. Young. 
  • On March 10, 1898, Warren Cole dies of a sudden heart attack. The Westville Indicator Obituary reports on March 17, 1898, that Cole and his daughter Alice were running late to his son William’s musical recital at the YMCA building in Chicago. Reaching the corner of Monroe and Dearborn, Cole suffers a heart attack and is moved to Colberts drug store, where he “expires.” His death leaves son-in-law William J. Young proprietor of Cole & Young.
  • On Oct. 23, 1899, the South Chicago jewelry store is burned down in a fire. On October 25, 1899, The Jewelers’ Circular reports: 

Chicago, Ill, Oct. 23 – Cole & Young’s jewelry store, 9144 Commercial Ave, South Chicago was burned to the ground this morning. The stock and building are a complete loss. Loss on stock, $6000; building, $2000. Insurance, $6000.

20th Century

  • The store is rebuilt, and on August 18, 1908, the Hammond Times reports:

Cole and Young Jewelers at 9144 Commercial avenue, have already broken ground for Improvements to their building. A second story will be added together with the floor space in the rear.”

  • Larry Mollo
    Mollo displays a portfolio that was presented to Cole & Young Co. President William J. Gibson on Christmas Day in 1920 after the business was incorporated. (Photo: Jennifer Yos)

    January, 1920, in Springfield, IL, William J. Young, Alice C. Young, and William J. Gibson together petition the state legislature to incorporate Cole and Young. Two weeks later, on January 31st, their corporation is approved.

  • On December 3, 1920, William J. Young dies while in Miami, Florida. He and his wife Alice have no surviving heirs, and Cole & Young employees take over operating the business. In the following five decades, the business is subsequently run by a series of owners: William J. Gibson, Strassburger, and Charles Jenkins.
  • On June 28, 1973, twenty-year old Larry Mollo is approached by a South Chicago banker who encourages him to purchase the business from Charles Jenkins. Two weeks later, Mollo takes possession of Cole & Young on June 28, 1973. As Mollo tells it,

“I used to sell stuff out of the trunk of my car when I was in high school, and one day I was at the Steel City Bank, running an errand for my father—who was always in business—and the President of the bank came up to me with an older gentleman, and says—he called me by my nickname Lonnie—he says, ‘Lonnie, why don’t you buy Charlie’s store?’ he says, ‘—Cole and Young.’ Cole and Young!…I pull my pockets out, I say, ‘This is why I can’t buy it.’  He says, ‘No, we’ll take care of that.’ So a couple of weeks later I own the business. I was still twenty years old. I was just a local kid and they always saw me working and running errands. I learned so much from the old-timers that were in business for years. We’d go to lunch and it was like going to class. They’d tell you how to handle situations, and it was just remarkable. Now, people don’t even want to talk to one another. A local lawyer Ron Buoscio … told the owner, ‘Give him the keys. You’ll have your money next Wednesday.’”  

  • In 1974, Jewelers of America, Inc. award Cole & Young Jewelers a 100 Club First Place Certificate for “over 100 years of continuous service.”
Cole & Young
The Jewelers 100 Club certificate Cole & Young was awarded by Jewelers of America, Inc. for 100 years of continuous service. (Photo: Jennifer Yos)
  • On Sept. 7, 1976, Mollo follows his customer base, moving Cole & Young Jewelers from 9144 Commercial Avenue, South Chicago, to its current address at 3341 Ridge Road, Lansing, IL.
Cole & Young
Hanging on the wall of Cole & Young Jewelry in Lansing is an entry door push bar salvaged from the store’s former South Chicago location. (Photo: Jennifer Yos)

21st Century

  • On March 23, 2017, according to a hand-written log Mollo has been keeping on the job since 1981, he changes his 60,000th watch battery. Mid-America Jewelry News does a write-up (Volume 16, No. 8) on this unique achievement, crowning Mollo “king of watch batteries” and noting his friendly customer service and reasonable pricing. Mollo has kept and continues to keep the price of battery replacement at $5 per watch ever since 1992. He hopes to reach 78,000 watch replacements by his 2021 closing.
  • In December 2020, Mollo makes the difficult decision to close shop some time after the New Year.


Reminiscing on his years in Lansing, Mollo fondly recalls Lansing people he would see passing by or regulars who would stop in. Among his friends, he recalls former White Sox and Cubs pitcher Steve Trout, who had lived in Lansing, and would often come to visit, and many current and former Lansing business owners with whom he still has contact. He also will miss a couple of ‘jobbers’ that have come in every day for 44 years. He contends the best part of the job is the people. “Am I the richest jeweler in the world? No,” Mollo acknowledges,  “But am I the happiest?  Quite possibly.”

Larry Mollo plans to close Cole & Young Co. Jewelers soon after the first of the new year. Cole & Young Co. Jewelers is located at 3341 Ridge Road, Lansing, IL.

Sources cited in this article were accessed from


Previous articleCOVID-19 data and visuals published December 22, 2020
Next articleObituary: Larry Medendorp
Jennifer Yos
Jennifer Yos grew up on Walter Street in Lansing with nine siblings. She attended St. Ann’s School and T.F. South, and she earned a BA in the Teaching of English from the University of Illinois, Chicago, and a MS in Education: Curriculum and Instruction from the University of St. Francis, Joliet. For 34 years she taught English, as well as Creative Writing and Drama, at Lincoln-Way High School. She dabbled in freelance journalism for the Joliet Herald News Living section. Now retired, Jennifer appreciates the opportunity to write for The Lansing Journal and is uplifted by the variety of positive people she has already met who are making a difference in Lansing.


  1. We wish he very best of luck to Larry and his wfe ! I am sorry t see another emty business on Ridge Rd, but I am sure more to follow . Like Larry said this virus and taxes not ony they hurting him but all the small businesses ! Way to go Crook County and Lansing !

  2. Enjoyed reading the interesting article on the history of Cole and Young.
    Congratulations on your well deserved retirement, Larry…..My Oregonian friends and I will miss stopping by and visiting with you. I wish you all of God’s blessings.
    Take care, Jeannine

  3. I will surely miss the great conversations while doing business with Larry. He was a good connection to many old friends and a great businessman!

  4. Very interesting article! I loved the description of how you sold stuff out of your car and ended up owning the business. Congratulations on your upcoming retirement, Larry, and on all your years of success!

  5. Lonnie, congratulations on a long and great run, now we can finally get together for lunch again. Merry Christmas to you and Barb and your family.

  6. Congratulations to you and Barb on your well deserved retirement. From the first time I walked in your store for a sales appointment in 1988, I knew we would be friends for life. It’s been a pleasure working with you. Together we sure made a lot of brides happy !
    Your are one of the most honest and generous clients I have met in business in my 35 year history and you treated all your clients the same. You are the real hidden gem on Ridge Road. Unfortunately, the world and society has changed so much in recent years to appreciate all you brought to the community.
    Once again, congratulations!
    The best is yet to come! Love you guy!

  7. We wish you and Barb the best of luck. I have known you a long time and we continue our friendship. You will enjoy retirement. You deserve it. May a long and healthy life await you and Barb! We will be in touch!

    Ed and JoAnn Corrigan

  8. Lonnie! I’ve patronized your shop for many years now–pretty much just for watch batteries and watch bands. (In fact, my wife happened to be your 75,000th watch battery customer back on February 22nd!) But I’ve greatly enjoyed chatting with you and will truly miss your store, your fine service, and above all, YOU personally. Quite a loss to Ridge Road, to Lansing, and to me.

    I’m already missing you, my friend. I wish you and Barb the very best in retirement. Stay well.

    Fondly, a good Mendel Man,
    Robert Porche

  9. It has been a pleasure to converse with a fellow jeweler of such a high caliber over the 30 or so years I have known Larry. He has always been, and continues to be, a class act. The business community and citizens of Lansing are loosing a great asset. We’ll miss you Larry.

  10. What a very special history and business. I’m so sorry to see them close. Who will we take our watches to? Also, Larry made many beautiful custom rings and earrings for me…so affordable. Indiana customers will miss Larry (and Barb). With the taxes they were being charged on such a small space, it probably didn’t make sense to keep going. Our loss. Miss you.

Comments are closed.